What's new
Cystic Fibrosis Forum (EXP)

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

bronchs

S

semperfiohana

Guest
has anyone not had a bronch done? i've never had one done. the first time i was admited to the hospital, the doctor i had (at the peds clinic) tired to do one on me. here's where the problem occurred. when i was in 2nd grade, maybe first i had polyps removed from my nose. so obviously i have some scar tissue there. well the doctor ordered one and my mom decided to let them try. here is where the problem was...they tried to go up my nose and into my lungs. let's see..scar tissue + hose=a no go. and on top of that I WAS FREAKING AWAKE!!! no sedation or drugs to keep me calm. so needless to say they didn't get their bronch. and it's never been brought up or attempted again. so i was just wondering if anyone else hasn't had one.
 
S

semperfiohana

Guest
has anyone not had a bronch done? i've never had one done. the first time i was admited to the hospital, the doctor i had (at the peds clinic) tired to do one on me. here's where the problem occurred. when i was in 2nd grade, maybe first i had polyps removed from my nose. so obviously i have some scar tissue there. well the doctor ordered one and my mom decided to let them try. here is where the problem was...they tried to go up my nose and into my lungs. let's see..scar tissue + hose=a no go. and on top of that I WAS FREAKING AWAKE!!! no sedation or drugs to keep me calm. so needless to say they didn't get their bronch. and it's never been brought up or attempted again. so i was just wondering if anyone else hasn't had one.
 
S

semperfiohana

Guest
has anyone not had a bronch done? i've never had one done. the first time i was admited to the hospital, the doctor i had (at the peds clinic) tired to do one on me. here's where the problem occurred. when i was in 2nd grade, maybe first i had polyps removed from my nose. so obviously i have some scar tissue there. well the doctor ordered one and my mom decided to let them try. here is where the problem was...they tried to go up my nose and into my lungs. let's see..scar tissue + hose=a no go. and on top of that I WAS FREAKING AWAKE!!! no sedation or drugs to keep me calm. so needless to say they didn't get their bronch. and it's never been brought up or attempted again. so i was just wondering if anyone else hasn't had one.
 
S

semperfiohana

Guest
has anyone not had a bronch done? i've never had one done. the first time i was admited to the hospital, the doctor i had (at the peds clinic) tired to do one on me. here's where the problem occurred. when i was in 2nd grade, maybe first i had polyps removed from my nose. so obviously i have some scar tissue there. well the doctor ordered one and my mom decided to let them try. here is where the problem was...they tried to go up my nose and into my lungs. let's see..scar tissue + hose=a no go. and on top of that I WAS FREAKING AWAKE!!! no sedation or drugs to keep me calm. so needless to say they didn't get their bronch. and it's never been brought up or attempted again. so i was just wondering if anyone else hasn't had one.
 
S

semperfiohana

Guest
has anyone not had a bronch done? i've never had one done. the first time i was admited to the hospital, the doctor i had (at the peds clinic) tired to do one on me. here's where the problem occurred. when i was in 2nd grade, maybe first i had polyps removed from my nose. so obviously i have some scar tissue there. well the doctor ordered one and my mom decided to let them try. here is where the problem was...they tried to go up my nose and into my lungs. let's see..scar tissue + hose=a no go. and on top of that I WAS FREAKING AWAKE!!! no sedation or drugs to keep me calm. so needless to say they didn't get their bronch. and it's never been brought up or attempted again. so i was just wondering if anyone else hasn't had one.
<br />
 

Nightwriter

New member
I haven't had a bronch either (knock wood), although I've had lots of offers. I first got sick when I was 21 after a bout of pneumonia that never went away.

About a year later, they found pseudomonas and I went into the hospital for IV treatments. When the doctor said he wanted to do a bronch, I asked, Why? Is it absolutely necessary? Would you change my treatment?" He said, "No, but it might give us a name for your disease."

They suspected adult CF. I had pseudomonas which was being treated-- so to have a bronch to label the disease -- not a good enough reason.

Another time I was in the hospital (pseudomonas again) a different doctor wanted to go in and suck out the mucus. I said, "But I'm coughing it out without a problem. And I'm getting better." Again. No thanks.

That same doctor offered a bronch again when I was really sick with pseudomonas and hemoptysis. I asked if I could wait a day and see if the IV antibiotics would stop the bleeding and it did stop.

I've had others suggest bronchs too. I asked my present doctor whom I trust, if it would have been a good idea for me to have had a broch. She said, absolutely not. She said she prefers less invasive ways of opening the airways and getting the mucous out. As far as diagnosis, CT scans really give a lot of information. Although you don't want them too often either.

For me, the biggest negative is there is always the possibility of introducing new bacteria from improperly sterilized equipment. Not to mention there are doctors who make a lot of money doing bronchs all the time. And if the culture shows what the bugs are and you respond to your treatments-- what's the point?

I am not saying that bronchs are never necessary. There may be other reasons other than what I've mentioned for their use. I can only say that for me the question always was and is to anything invasive or possible harmful, "Is it absolutely necessary? And will it change how you are going to treat me and how?

You asked a simple question and I gave a way too long answer.
 

Nightwriter

New member
I haven't had a bronch either (knock wood), although I've had lots of offers. I first got sick when I was 21 after a bout of pneumonia that never went away.

About a year later, they found pseudomonas and I went into the hospital for IV treatments. When the doctor said he wanted to do a bronch, I asked, Why? Is it absolutely necessary? Would you change my treatment?" He said, "No, but it might give us a name for your disease."

They suspected adult CF. I had pseudomonas which was being treated-- so to have a bronch to label the disease -- not a good enough reason.

Another time I was in the hospital (pseudomonas again) a different doctor wanted to go in and suck out the mucus. I said, "But I'm coughing it out without a problem. And I'm getting better." Again. No thanks.

That same doctor offered a bronch again when I was really sick with pseudomonas and hemoptysis. I asked if I could wait a day and see if the IV antibiotics would stop the bleeding and it did stop.

I've had others suggest bronchs too. I asked my present doctor whom I trust, if it would have been a good idea for me to have had a broch. She said, absolutely not. She said she prefers less invasive ways of opening the airways and getting the mucous out. As far as diagnosis, CT scans really give a lot of information. Although you don't want them too often either.

For me, the biggest negative is there is always the possibility of introducing new bacteria from improperly sterilized equipment. Not to mention there are doctors who make a lot of money doing bronchs all the time. And if the culture shows what the bugs are and you respond to your treatments-- what's the point?

I am not saying that bronchs are never necessary. There may be other reasons other than what I've mentioned for their use. I can only say that for me the question always was and is to anything invasive or possible harmful, "Is it absolutely necessary? And will it change how you are going to treat me and how?

You asked a simple question and I gave a way too long answer.
 

Nightwriter

New member
I haven't had a bronch either (knock wood), although I've had lots of offers. I first got sick when I was 21 after a bout of pneumonia that never went away.

About a year later, they found pseudomonas and I went into the hospital for IV treatments. When the doctor said he wanted to do a bronch, I asked, Why? Is it absolutely necessary? Would you change my treatment?" He said, "No, but it might give us a name for your disease."

They suspected adult CF. I had pseudomonas which was being treated-- so to have a bronch to label the disease -- not a good enough reason.

Another time I was in the hospital (pseudomonas again) a different doctor wanted to go in and suck out the mucus. I said, "But I'm coughing it out without a problem. And I'm getting better." Again. No thanks.

That same doctor offered a bronch again when I was really sick with pseudomonas and hemoptysis. I asked if I could wait a day and see if the IV antibiotics would stop the bleeding and it did stop.

I've had others suggest bronchs too. I asked my present doctor whom I trust, if it would have been a good idea for me to have had a broch. She said, absolutely not. She said she prefers less invasive ways of opening the airways and getting the mucous out. As far as diagnosis, CT scans really give a lot of information. Although you don't want them too often either.

For me, the biggest negative is there is always the possibility of introducing new bacteria from improperly sterilized equipment. Not to mention there are doctors who make a lot of money doing bronchs all the time. And if the culture shows what the bugs are and you respond to your treatments-- what's the point?

I am not saying that bronchs are never necessary. There may be other reasons other than what I've mentioned for their use. I can only say that for me the question always was and is to anything invasive or possible harmful, "Is it absolutely necessary? And will it change how you are going to treat me and how?

You asked a simple question and I gave a way too long answer.
 

Nightwriter

New member
I haven't had a bronch either (knock wood), although I've had lots of offers. I first got sick when I was 21 after a bout of pneumonia that never went away.

About a year later, they found pseudomonas and I went into the hospital for IV treatments. When the doctor said he wanted to do a bronch, I asked, Why? Is it absolutely necessary? Would you change my treatment?" He said, "No, but it might give us a name for your disease."

They suspected adult CF. I had pseudomonas which was being treated-- so to have a bronch to label the disease -- not a good enough reason.

Another time I was in the hospital (pseudomonas again) a different doctor wanted to go in and suck out the mucus. I said, "But I'm coughing it out without a problem. And I'm getting better." Again. No thanks.

That same doctor offered a bronch again when I was really sick with pseudomonas and hemoptysis. I asked if I could wait a day and see if the IV antibiotics would stop the bleeding and it did stop.

I've had others suggest bronchs too. I asked my present doctor whom I trust, if it would have been a good idea for me to have had a broch. She said, absolutely not. She said she prefers less invasive ways of opening the airways and getting the mucous out. As far as diagnosis, CT scans really give a lot of information. Although you don't want them too often either.

For me, the biggest negative is there is always the possibility of introducing new bacteria from improperly sterilized equipment. Not to mention there are doctors who make a lot of money doing bronchs all the time. And if the culture shows what the bugs are and you respond to your treatments-- what's the point?

I am not saying that bronchs are never necessary. There may be other reasons other than what I've mentioned for their use. I can only say that for me the question always was and is to anything invasive or possible harmful, "Is it absolutely necessary? And will it change how you are going to treat me and how?

You asked a simple question and I gave a way too long answer.
 

Nightwriter

New member
I haven't had a bronch either (knock wood), although I've had lots of offers. I first got sick when I was 21 after a bout of pneumonia that never went away.
<br />
<br />About a year later, they found pseudomonas and I went into the hospital for IV treatments. When the doctor said he wanted to do a bronch, I asked, Why? Is it absolutely necessary? Would you change my treatment?" He said, "No, but it might give us a name for your disease."
<br />
<br />They suspected adult CF. I had pseudomonas which was being treated-- so to have a bronch to label the disease -- not a good enough reason.
<br />
<br />Another time I was in the hospital (pseudomonas again) a different doctor wanted to go in and suck out the mucus. I said, "But I'm coughing it out without a problem. And I'm getting better." Again. No thanks.
<br />
<br />That same doctor offered a bronch again when I was really sick with pseudomonas and hemoptysis. I asked if I could wait a day and see if the IV antibiotics would stop the bleeding and it did stop.
<br />
<br />I've had others suggest bronchs too. I asked my present doctor whom I trust, if it would have been a good idea for me to have had a broch. She said, absolutely not. She said she prefers less invasive ways of opening the airways and getting the mucous out. As far as diagnosis, CT scans really give a lot of information. Although you don't want them too often either.
<br />
<br />For me, the biggest negative is there is always the possibility of introducing new bacteria from improperly sterilized equipment. Not to mention there are doctors who make a lot of money doing bronchs all the time. And if the culture shows what the bugs are and you respond to your treatments-- what's the point?
<br />
<br />I am not saying that bronchs are never necessary. There may be other reasons other than what I've mentioned for their use. I can only say that for me the question always was and is to anything invasive or possible harmful, "Is it absolutely necessary? And will it change how you are going to treat me and how?
<br />
<br />You asked a simple question and I gave a way too long answer.
 

JazzysMom

New member
I didnt have any bronchs done on until my admission in January. So many people seemed surprised by that too!
<br />
<br />
 

Landy

New member
I like Nighwriter's view...if it isn't going to change the course of action, then why bother?

And no, I've not had one yet either.
 

Landy

New member
I like Nighwriter's view...if it isn't going to change the course of action, then why bother?

And no, I've not had one yet either.
 

Landy

New member
I like Nighwriter's view...if it isn't going to change the course of action, then why bother?

And no, I've not had one yet either.
 

Landy

New member
I like Nighwriter's view...if it isn't going to change the course of action, then why bother?

And no, I've not had one yet either.
 

Landy

New member
I like Nighwriter's view...if it isn't going to change the course of action, then why bother?
<br />
<br />And no, I've not had one yet either.
 
Top