What's new
Cystic Fibrosis Forum (EXP)

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

How To Share Online Information and Links to Articles

J

Jade

Guest
But wouldn't a site like this be able to claim <i>fair use </i>or <i>educational use </i>if someone was confronted.....given the info is health related, ect and not copying someones novel for example. Of course fair use barely qualifies as a law becuase even most courts are confused on it's meaning.
 
J

Jade

Guest
But wouldn't a site like this be able to claim <i>fair use </i>or <i>educational use </i>if someone was confronted.....given the info is health related, ect and not copying someones novel for example. Of course fair use barely qualifies as a law becuase even most courts are confused on it's meaning.
 

JazzysMom

New member
<div class="FTQUOTE"><begin quote><i>Originally posted by: <b>Jade</b></i>

But wouldn't a site like this be able to claim <i>fair use </i>or <i>educational use </i>if someone was confronted.....given the info is health related, ect and not copying someones novel for example. Of course fair use barely qualifies as a law becuase even most courts are confused on it's meaning.</end quote></div>

I also would think a financial profit would need to be made, yes?!
 

JazzysMom

New member
<div class="FTQUOTE"><begin quote><i>Originally posted by: <b>Jade</b></i>

But wouldn't a site like this be able to claim <i>fair use </i>or <i>educational use </i>if someone was confronted.....given the info is health related, ect and not copying someones novel for example. Of course fair use barely qualifies as a law becuase even most courts are confused on it's meaning.</end quote></div>

I also would think a financial profit would need to be made, yes?!
 

JazzysMom

New member
<div class="FTQUOTE"><begin quote><i>Originally posted by: <b>Jade</b></i>

But wouldn't a site like this be able to claim <i>fair use </i>or <i>educational use </i>if someone was confronted.....given the info is health related, ect and not copying someones novel for example. Of course fair use barely qualifies as a law becuase even most courts are confused on it's meaning.</end quote></div>

I also would think a financial profit would need to be made, yes?!
 

EnergyGal

New member
I have copied and pasted articles and placed it on a forum before and always gave credit to an author or placed the url address. If I did not do it a proper fashion oh well. I try and remember all the rules. This is a forum for sharing good information and most of us have good intentions.
 

EnergyGal

New member
I have copied and pasted articles and placed it on a forum before and always gave credit to an author or placed the url address. If I did not do it a proper fashion oh well. I try and remember all the rules. This is a forum for sharing good information and most of us have good intentions.
 

EnergyGal

New member
I have copied and pasted articles and placed it on a forum before and always gave credit to an author or placed the url address. If I did not do it a proper fashion oh well. I try and remember all the rules. This is a forum for sharing good information and most of us have good intentions.
 

lightNlife

New member
<div class="FTQUOTE"><begin quote>
I also would think a financial profit would need to be made, yes?!</end quote></div>

Sometimes whether a profit is being made makes a difference in whether the author wants to take legal action, but a person does not have to be making money from someone's work in order to be infringing on copyright. As far as the fair use thing, again, that's such a gray area and is difficult to pin down from a legal standpoint.

Let me give you an example of a problem I recently had regarding copyright infringement. I published an original article with a certain media source online. It was a one time printing rights, meaning that if I wanted to have it published elsewhere I could do that too. So, I submitted the same article to another source letting them know of the other place I'd published it.

It was rejected. They claimed that my article had been published other places than what I had disclosed. A quick Google search on my own time proved that in fact, my article in its entirety was posted on someone's website without my permission. Although that website was not making money from positing my material, their act of copyright infringement had hurt my ability to make money from the article. (It wasn't a lot of money, but when you're working freelance we have to take what we can get sometimes)

Like Risa said, there are a lot of rules to follow. I wish I knew the details of all of them, but really it doesn't have much bearing on this forum to discuss it here. Bottom line is that we should all do what we can to be sure we share online content in appropriate ways. Summarize things in your own words and provide author information and links whenever possible.

Thanks!
 

lightNlife

New member
<div class="FTQUOTE"><begin quote>
I also would think a financial profit would need to be made, yes?!</end quote></div>

Sometimes whether a profit is being made makes a difference in whether the author wants to take legal action, but a person does not have to be making money from someone's work in order to be infringing on copyright. As far as the fair use thing, again, that's such a gray area and is difficult to pin down from a legal standpoint.

Let me give you an example of a problem I recently had regarding copyright infringement. I published an original article with a certain media source online. It was a one time printing rights, meaning that if I wanted to have it published elsewhere I could do that too. So, I submitted the same article to another source letting them know of the other place I'd published it.

It was rejected. They claimed that my article had been published other places than what I had disclosed. A quick Google search on my own time proved that in fact, my article in its entirety was posted on someone's website without my permission. Although that website was not making money from positing my material, their act of copyright infringement had hurt my ability to make money from the article. (It wasn't a lot of money, but when you're working freelance we have to take what we can get sometimes)

Like Risa said, there are a lot of rules to follow. I wish I knew the details of all of them, but really it doesn't have much bearing on this forum to discuss it here. Bottom line is that we should all do what we can to be sure we share online content in appropriate ways. Summarize things in your own words and provide author information and links whenever possible.

Thanks!
 

lightNlife

New member
<div class="FTQUOTE"><begin quote>
I also would think a financial profit would need to be made, yes?!</end quote></div>

Sometimes whether a profit is being made makes a difference in whether the author wants to take legal action, but a person does not have to be making money from someone's work in order to be infringing on copyright. As far as the fair use thing, again, that's such a gray area and is difficult to pin down from a legal standpoint.

Let me give you an example of a problem I recently had regarding copyright infringement. I published an original article with a certain media source online. It was a one time printing rights, meaning that if I wanted to have it published elsewhere I could do that too. So, I submitted the same article to another source letting them know of the other place I'd published it.

It was rejected. They claimed that my article had been published other places than what I had disclosed. A quick Google search on my own time proved that in fact, my article in its entirety was posted on someone's website without my permission. Although that website was not making money from positing my material, their act of copyright infringement had hurt my ability to make money from the article. (It wasn't a lot of money, but when you're working freelance we have to take what we can get sometimes)

Like Risa said, there are a lot of rules to follow. I wish I knew the details of all of them, but really it doesn't have much bearing on this forum to discuss it here. Bottom line is that we should all do what we can to be sure we share online content in appropriate ways. Summarize things in your own words and provide author information and links whenever possible.

Thanks!
 

dyza

New member
Anyone is free to use anything that I may write, which is original, well to me, but then I dont make the distinction between what is mine and what belongs to others.

Your point is taken here LightNlife, but does much infringement take place at this forum?
 

dyza

New member
Anyone is free to use anything that I may write, which is original, well to me, but then I dont make the distinction between what is mine and what belongs to others.

Your point is taken here LightNlife, but does much infringement take place at this forum?
 

dyza

New member
Anyone is free to use anything that I may write, which is original, well to me, but then I dont make the distinction between what is mine and what belongs to others.

Your point is taken here LightNlife, but does much infringement take place at this forum?
 
Top