What's new
Cystic Fibrosis Forum (EXP)

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Why Hypertonice Saline (should) Work

lightNlife

New member
<div class="FTQUOTE"><begin quote><i>Originally posted by: <b>anonymous</b></i>

Before you try to put it "more basic", you need to understand it yourself.</end quote></div>


I do understand it, I just couldn't describe it very well. My apologies. In any case, I was focusing on the osmolarity aspect of it when I was processing the description in my head and unfortunately, it didn't come out on the page very well.

Still, the basic reason why it works it because it increases moisture in the lung environment. Still, even if our body's cells are triggered to release moisture in the presence of salt, the multiple and varying medications many of us are on (particularly meds that block allergens) we tend to be dehydrated anyway. Delivering medication in nebulized form, (eg. HS) potentially brings about the same physical change to the body's environment as does a good steamy shower, or the use of a humidifier.

This is why getting hung up on hyper-hypo-iso terminology is so confusing. I only muddied the water by attempting to explain that. My overall intent was to highlight the benefit of the <b>PHYSICAL</b> change that takes place, not the chemical change.
 

anonymous

New member
The meds we nebulize add moisture to the top of the mucus. The HS draws water out of the cells adding moisture under the mucus (in theory) allowing the lungs to clear it out. It adds the moisture layer needed for the cillia in our lungs to work.
 

anonymous

New member
The meds we nebulize add moisture to the top of the mucus. The HS draws water out of the cells adding moisture under the mucus (in theory) allowing the lungs to clear it out. It adds the moisture layer needed for the cillia in our lungs to work.
 

anonymous

New member
The meds we nebulize add moisture to the top of the mucus. The HS draws water out of the cells adding moisture under the mucus (in theory) allowing the lungs to clear it out. It adds the moisture layer needed for the cillia in our lungs to work.
 

lightNlife

New member
Since you're too shy to sign in and prefer to critique anonymously, I can't send you a PM. Is <a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="http://livingwellwithcf.blogspot.com/2006/03/why-hypertonic-saline-treatments.html">this updated description</a> more to your fastidious liking?
 

lightNlife

New member
Since you're too shy to sign in and prefer to critique anonymously, I can't send you a PM. Is <a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="http://livingwellwithcf.blogspot.com/2006/03/why-hypertonic-saline-treatments.html">this updated description</a> more to your fastidious liking?
 

lightNlife

New member
Since you're too shy to sign in and prefer to critique anonymously, I can't send you a PM. Is <a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="http://livingwellwithcf.blogspot.com/2006/03/why-hypertonic-saline-treatments.html">this updated description</a> more to your fastidious liking?
 

anonymous

New member
together y'all have done a great job of explaining how it works. I get it for the first time ever. now a question to you guys. how important is it that it's 7% my doctor feels that they haven't really proven that it has to be 7%, he thinks me being on 3% is still going to have the same effect. I think he worries that 7% long term is going to be proven to be too strong an irritant on the lungs. after all scar tissue is one of our greatest enemies.

LouLou
28 f/w/cf
 

anonymous

New member
together y'all have done a great job of explaining how it works. I get it for the first time ever. now a question to you guys. how important is it that it's 7% my doctor feels that they haven't really proven that it has to be 7%, he thinks me being on 3% is still going to have the same effect. I think he worries that 7% long term is going to be proven to be too strong an irritant on the lungs. after all scar tissue is one of our greatest enemies.

LouLou
28 f/w/cf
 

anonymous

New member
together y'all have done a great job of explaining how it works. I get it for the first time ever. now a question to you guys. how important is it that it's 7% my doctor feels that they haven't really proven that it has to be 7%, he thinks me being on 3% is still going to have the same effect. I think he worries that 7% long term is going to be proven to be too strong an irritant on the lungs. after all scar tissue is one of our greatest enemies.

LouLou
28 f/w/cf
 

anonymous

New member
<b>Think of the amount of water in the solution as the sandwich from our picnic example. Inhaling the hypertonic saline is the same as donating a sandwich to the guys on the other picnic blanket. Similarly, the body pulls the water out of the inhaled solution and applies it to our cells. </b>

Since you asked.....I believe this is incorrect. It doesn't take water from the solution, it pulls water out of the cells.

I just don't like it when people who claim to know science, explain sceintifically why something should work, and then get the science all wrong. I'm not being picky, I just like my facts to be factual.

M-the anonymous
 

anonymous

New member
<b>Think of the amount of water in the solution as the sandwich from our picnic example. Inhaling the hypertonic saline is the same as donating a sandwich to the guys on the other picnic blanket. Similarly, the body pulls the water out of the inhaled solution and applies it to our cells. </b>

Since you asked.....I believe this is incorrect. It doesn't take water from the solution, it pulls water out of the cells.

I just don't like it when people who claim to know science, explain sceintifically why something should work, and then get the science all wrong. I'm not being picky, I just like my facts to be factual.

M-the anonymous
 

anonymous

New member
<b>Think of the amount of water in the solution as the sandwich from our picnic example. Inhaling the hypertonic saline is the same as donating a sandwich to the guys on the other picnic blanket. Similarly, the body pulls the water out of the inhaled solution and applies it to our cells. </b>

Since you asked.....I believe this is incorrect. It doesn't take water from the solution, it pulls water out of the cells.

I just don't like it when people who claim to know science, explain sceintifically why something should work, and then get the science all wrong. I'm not being picky, I just like my facts to be factual.

M-the anonymous
 

anonymous

New member
that's why I asked for the feedback--it doesn't do anyone any good if I can't explain something well, even if I do understand it in my head.

-lightNlife
 

anonymous

New member
that's why I asked for the feedback--it doesn't do anyone any good if I can't explain something well, even if I do understand it in my head.

-lightNlife
 

anonymous

New member
that's why I asked for the feedback--it doesn't do anyone any good if I can't explain something well, even if I do understand it in my head.

-lightNlife
 

anonymous

New member
<div class="FTQUOTE"><begin quote><i>Originally posted by: <b>anonymous</b></i>

together y'all have done a great job of explaining how it works. I get it for the first time ever. now a question to you guys. how important is it that it's 7% my doctor feels that they haven't really proven that it has to be 7%, he thinks me being on 3% is still going to have the same effect. I think he worries that 7% long term is going to be proven to be too strong an irritant on the lungs. after all scar tissue is one of our greatest enemies.



LouLou

28 f/w/cf</end quote></div>


Off the top of my head, I recall reading something that 3% to 7% has been shown to be effective. If I find the article later I will post it.

M
 
Top